Trowel Tales: The AIA Blog

Help Preserve Archaeology in Greece
September 15, 2010 | by Sebastian Heath

Help Preserve Archaeology in Greece

Greece, a country in which many AIA members have worked or studied, has asked the United States to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) that would require documentation for objects coming into the U.S. that may have been illegally exported from Greece. The US already has MoUs with countries such as China, Cyprus, and Italy as well as many nations in Central and South America. Adding an agreement with Greece will be a major step forward in enabling the U.S. Government to help reduce the looting of sites and the destruction of our shared archaeological heritage. The MoU faces substantial opposition from collectors and dealers, particularly those who buy and sell ancient coins. Indeed, the U.S. government site where people can comment on the proposed MoU (link) now makes public some very strongly held opinions:

"Dear Madam or Sir, I write in opposition to the cultural property request from the government of Greece. As a relatively low-budget collector, I believe that granting this request will increase the cost of my collecting. This, while doing absolutely nothing to protect the cultural heritage of Greece" (See full comment)

or

"Coin collectors, beneficiaries of the free flow of coins around the world, have preserved these small pieces of history, often advancing their understanding through research and analysis. In the absence of a vibrant coin collecting hobby, millions of coins would ultimately be lost to posterity, taking their historical information content with them." (See full comment)

Archaeologists believe that ancient objects can make the greatest contribution to our understanding of the ancient world if information about their findspots is preserved and made public. The proposed MoU is one tool that will help preserve knowledge about past societies. But it is extremely important that the voices of professionals and enthusiasts alike are heard. If we do not write, the committee considering Greece's request cannot know what we think. If you would like to submit comments, go here and click on "Submit Comment". If you would like help with what to say, go to the AIA's page of information about the Cultural Property Advisory Committee, the body that will make the initial recommendation as to whether or not to enter into an agreement with Greece. It is very useful to look at the four determinations that the committee will use. It is important to note that Greece's archaeological heritage - including coins, ceramics, sculpture and other objects - is under threat. If you would like confirmation that this is the case, you can read David Gill's blog "Looting Matters". His recent post "Protecting the Archaeological Record of Greece" lists earlier posts that demonstrate the damage that illegal excavation and import has done to our understanding of Greece's rich past.

Comments

It is a disgrace that the USA has not entered into an MoU with Greece on this matter. I hope it does the decent thing as soon as possible.

Dear AIA Vice President Sebastian Heath;

It has come to my attention that Greece has asked on her own part for the United States of America to establish a bilateral agreement to protect her archaeological heritage by putting restrictions on Greek cultural property, upon the date of October 12th 2010. I am a student from Ponoka, Alberta and take pride in the Greek history that surrounds our daily lives in literature and studies. I have always been interested in the Greek forms of writing and how they lived through out the centuries. It would also be amazing to study and visit the great sanctuary of Delphi, to study how the oracle found their mystic powers and how the Greeks decided that it was the center of their world to see something like that in a life time is life changing. So by introducing the MoU to the public it would increase the awareness of information from Greece and her artifacts. I believe that this is crucial for the sake of preventing the past to being misinterpreted by those who do not fully understand the whole of Greek history and her artifacts. In conclusion I respectfully ask the Committee to go forth with the establishment of this agreement in the form of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of Greece.

Sincerely, Melissa Gartner

I am glad to be a member of your group.

This is about preserving not just Greece's history but our own foundation of our civilization. These cultural antiquities belong to humanity. Everyone today owes a level of respect to these important sites. We all are inheritors of this treasure. The world would be a sadder place without this history to see, to touch, to behold.

These sites must be preserved regardless of the cost.......once they are gone, they can never be replaced.

The SAFE page linked in the prior comment, and here, is excellent and I encourage everyone to read it.

-Sebastian.

Greece has a rich history dating back thousands of years. Preserving the Greek monuments will help us to learn how the world has become the way it is, attract tourists and contribute to the Greeks cultural pride. Without these monuments, part of the ancient world will truly be lost as they are irreplaceable. Please preserve these monuments for the benefit of Greece and the world.

Your Grecian past is for everyone on this planet--please help to preserve it!!

I can empathize with collectors and amateur historians about the cost or difficulty it may be to obtain a piece of history. There is just something about being able to savor a small window into the past. What I can't comprehend is how some people can put a price on history, or be against something that is trying to protect the archaeological record, process, and integrity of a nation. Just because someone wants something, doesn't mean they should have it if it is obtained illegally or through shady means.
The main idea behind a MoU is to give the past a fighting chance and for that country to be able to protect it's very foundations. Shame on people for being selfish by only wanting an item just for themselves. History is meant to be shared, or how else will we strive to not repeat it? Greece especially has an important historical influence on America. I would bet that Socrates, Aristotle, and Homer would be appalled that not protecting a people's archaeological heritage isn't a priority for the majority. I would like to be considered a small voice of support in a large sea of controversy. Please grant Greece a MoU so that their future can learn about their past.

Katie, I am a collector. I can assure you that the cost of owning a piece of history is a rather insignificant component of the collecting experience, which is mainly driven by the joy of kinesthetic learning. The debate over cultural property has been framed by some as an issue of preservation. The notion is that only a few are ennobled by training or appointment to be stewards of the past. Having known many independent scholars who contributed greatly to our knowledge of the past, this is not a position that I can accept. If an MOU were simply about a country protecting its foundations, there would be no reason to apply its terms to every broken potsherd, coin or belt buckle that was ever made by a past civilization. The MOU is really about control and I personally find that unsavory. If history is meant to be shared, why do some archaeologist choose to destroy excess utilitarian objects rather than allow private collectors to purchase them and fund further excavation? I suspect that you have been subjected to a heavy dose of propaganda and really know very little about what private collecting is or does for society in terms of preservation and altruistic contributions to "the rest" of society. I doubt that Socrates, Aristotle and Homer (whoever that was) would be appalled by private collectors -- more likely, they were collectors themselves. Finally, I'm at a loss to understand why you think that Greece needs every object every made by their society in order to learn about their past? Regards, Wayne

By all means, the historical sites should be preserved.

The SAFE web site has also posted background information and reasons why we should support the MoU here: http://www.savingantiquities.org/Greecemou.php

We also courage readers to join AIA's letter writing campaign.

Cindy Ho

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

AIA News

Dig Deeper

Email the AIA
Subscribe to the AIA e-Update

Sign Up!